Welcome to Cedar Valley Pizzeria
Cedar Valley Pizzeria, located in the heart of New Park, PA, is a charming gem that captures the essence of a welcoming, family-run eatery. Known for its delicious, homemade dishes, Cedar Valley offers an impressive selection of pizzas, subs, and baked goods. Customers rave about the perfectly baked Stromboli and mouthwatering cheesesteak subs, highlighting the generous portions and flavorful ingredients. The warm ambiance and friendly staff make every visit memorable. With homemade cookies, especially the famous peanut butter marshmallow variety, this pizzeria ensures that every meal is not just satisfying but also a delightful experience worth sharing.
Cedar Valley Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings
Hey there! I just wanted to take a moment to thank you for being such an amazing lady. Your incredible cooking brings so much joy to all of us, and your love for our country shines through in everything you do. Keep being you, because you inspire those around you every day!
Very good food. I took a carry out cheese steak and it was delicious. Cookies and baked goods looked freshly baked. I am regretting not getting dessert while I was there.
I've been stopping here for 3-4 years. For the longest time I only ever bought the drinks and their home made cookies. The peanut butter marshmallow cookies are fantastic! Within the last 12 months I've discovered their pizza is also one of the best around. This place is every bit of the little Ma and Pa shops you remember from years past. The food is great and the service is friendly.
Outstanding place for pizza!! Occasionally will have someone come in bring in pit beef which is first come first serve, signs will be posted in the area notifying when to go!! Very close to Maze Quest
This is a ma & pa kind of place that just makes you feel at home when you enter. All of the staff are wonderful and struck me as people who are just genuinely kind hearted. The inside is kept clean and neat, homemade cookies are displayed perfectly through an old school diner case which complimented the atmosphere well. The food was absolutely delicious. The personal Stromboli was baked to perfection and was a huge portion for such a low price. The cheesesteak sub is a new favorite and easily one of the best I have ever had. The meat was deliciously seasoned, the sub was well packed, the cheese melty, the fried onions blended perfectly. Even the BLT was done well. The pumpkin rolls were mouth watering and a sweet savory finish to top off a delicious dinner. I cannot say enough good things about this unexpected gem. From its atmosphere and people to its seemingly homemade recipes and prices, I can see why this shop has been around for so long. I only wish we had known about it sooner. I highly recommend a stop in for some food and good conversation if you're in the area.
Have been going here since around 1975, when Miss May and Pop-Pop had it, with video rentals back in the day. Moved back into the area and found their daughter Jo Anne had taken over for the family and the food is still awesome! Try the broasted chicken! Subs are great too. Pizza? Oh yeah! There's even a special low price pizza night which goes up each minute after it begins, fun stuff! (You'll have to check out the store to find out which night. Oh, did I mention Hersheys' Icecream and special soft serve flavors all through the summer?... Malts? Uh-huh. I could go on and on. Love this place and the family heritage our neighborhood is proud to have.
The food is pretty good. People are so friendly and welcoming. If you're passing through and our out of towners. I recommend the cold sub items. I am a local. And I'm grateful for a quality food source. Especially since I don't have to go to a Big Town to get it.
We stopped here on a whim, we live an hour away and are debating on coming back more than once. It’s an adorable mom& pop place, it looks a little precarious but it’s so worth it, everyone was so nice and it was very reasonably priced. Also 6 stars for the dogs I was able to pet!
Location
-
2560 New Park Rd, New Park, PA 17352, United States Hotline: +1 717-382-4337
Welcome to Cedar Valley Pizzeria, a charming culinary gem located at 2560 New Park Rd, New Park, PA. This delightful eatery embodies the essence of a true Ma and Pa establishment, boasting not just delicious food, but also a warm, inviting atmosphere that makes every visit feel like coming home. If you’re looking to satisfy your cravings with high-quality pizza or an array of hearty comfort foods, Cedar Valley is the place to be.
What truly sets Cedar Valley apart is the exceptional quality of their food, as echoed by satisfied customers. One reviewer praised the cheesesteak as “delicious,” noting the regret of not indulging in the tempting baked goods on display. The homemade cookies, particularly the peanut butter marshmallow variety, have gained a loyal following, making them a must-try for anyone with a sweet tooth.
The pizza here is exceptional, with a reputation for being one of the best in the region. It is prepared with a careful balance of flavors and freshness that is hard to find. Whether you’re opting for a personal Stromboli, which reviewers have described as perfectly baked and generously portioned, or enjoying a classic BLT, the culinary expertise at Cedar Valley shines through. One might argue that the cheesesteak sub is the star of the menu, packed with well-seasoned meat, melty cheese, and perfectly blended fried onions that promise to elevate your taste experience.
The ambiance at Cedar Valley Pizzeria adds to its charm. The establishment is clean and neat, with a nostalgic feel harkening back to simpler times. Customers have expressed their appreciation for the genuine kindness of the staff, which enhances the overall dining experience. As one reviewer noted, this isn’t just dining; it’s a chance for good food and good conversation. With homemade recipes that taste as if they came straight from a loving family kitchen and prices that won’t break the bank, it’s easy to see why Cedar Valley Pizzeria has garnered such loyal patronage.
For anyone in the New Park area or just passing through, Cedar Valley Pizzeria promises a memorable meal filled with heartwarming flavors and friendly service. Stop by for a slice, a sandwich, or just to chat with the wonderful staff—you won’t leave disappointed!